Sedevacantism Examined: Can the Pope Lose the Papacy? John Salza & Robert Siscoe

About this sermon

Can a pope become a heretic? If so, does he automatically lose the papacy? In this detailed discussion, John Salza and Robert Siscoe, authors of True Pope? False Pope?, examine one of the most controversial questions in Catholic theology. Drawing upon St. Robert Bellarmine, Cajetan, Suarez, St. Alphonsus Liguori, Ludwig Ott, and traditional Catholic theology, they explain the Church's understanding of: Formal vs. material heresy Occult vs. notorious heresy Membership in the Catholic Church The external and internal bonds of the Church Visibility of the Church Apostolic succession Jurisdiction Ecclesiastical office Can a pope lose his office? Why sedevacantism misunderstands Catholic ecclesiology Universal and peaceful acceptance Sedeprivationism explained Pope Francis and theological speculation Historical examples from Church history This presentation provides a comprehensive treatment of one of the most debated theological subjects facing Catholics today. "The gates of hell shall not prevail against it." — Matthew 16:18 00:00 You Are the Resistance 00:45 Introduction 01:19 Opening Prayer 02:04 Revolutionary Movements in Church History 04:26 What Is Sedevacantism? 06:14 Why the Crisis Makes Sedevacantism Attractive 08:47 Introducing Robert Siscoe 10:12 Ecclesiology as the Foundation 10:58 The Visibility of the Church 12:33 Apostolic Succession Explained 14:20 Why the Church Must Have a Hierarchy 16:04 Invisible Church vs Visible Church 17:49 What Is Heresy? 18:44 Formal Heresy Explained 20:24 Ambiguity vs Actual Heresy 22:53 Internal vs External Bonds of the Church 25:41 The Three External Bonds 27:03 Profession of Faith Explained 30:33 How the Social Bond Is Maintained 32:50 Public Sinners Still Remaining Members 35:47 Four Categories of Heresy 39:44 Formal vs Material Heretics 43:35 Occult Heresy Explained 46:22 What Is Notorious Heresy? 48:28 Can Clerics Lose Office Automatically? 52:09 How Does a Bishop or Pope Lose Office? 56:14 Warnings Before Removal 58:47 Why Canonical Warnings Matter 1:01:01 Bellarmine on Judging a Pope 1:04:02 Bellarmine on Occult Heretics 1:10:01 Sedeprivationism Explained 1:14:32 "For Many" vs "For All" 1:15:35 Baptism of Desire 1:17:18 How the Church Recognizes Separation 1:19:22 Questions on the Current Crisis 1:22:09 Catholics Becoming Orthodox 1:23:42 Who Can Judge a Pope? 1:24:33 Historical Examples 1:26:04 Could Pope Francis Be Declared Invalid? 1:26:45 Universal and Peaceful Acceptance 1:27:21 Future Discussion Preview 1:29:02 Closing Prayer http://www.trueorfalsepope.com/ to get the book (which is very good) 🔴🔴🔴🔴🔴🔴🔴🔴🔴🔴🔴🔴🔴🔴🔴🔴🔴🔴🔴 Support Catholic Businesses here - https://sensusfidelium.com/catholic-businesses/ Sensus Fidelium Press - https://sensusfideliumpress.com/ Sensus Fidelium Apps - https://sensusfidelium.tv/ Support Sensus Fidelium - https://sensusfidelium.com/donate-support/ 🔴🔴🔴🔴🔴🔴🔴🔴🔴🔴🔴🔴🔴🔴🔴🔴🔴🔴🔴 🙏🏻PLEASE HELP OUR CHANNEL GROW 🙏🏻 ▶️ 1. Become a Channel Patron: https://www.patreon.com/SensusFidelium ▶️ 2. Visit the website https://www.sensusfidelium.us for Gueranger, Saint of the Day, Apologetics, Meditation by the Saints, Scripture Study and more. ▶️ 3. BitChute --- https://www.bitchute.com/channel/Sensus_Fidelium/ ▶️ 4. LBRY.tv --- https://lbry.tv/@SensusFidelium:c ▶️ 5. UGETube - https://videos.utahgunexchange.com/@Sensus%20Fidelium ▶️ 6. Paypal, Bitcoin, Anedot, Stripe, Square & PO Box donations - https://sensusfidelium.us/donate-support/ ▶️ 7. YouTube: Click Subscribe, then Click "Notification Bell" = 🔔 Please "Like" our videos so that Youtube shares it to others by clicking the "Like" thumbs-up under the video = 👍🏻 ▶️ 8. Please share this video 📲, and help others find Christ inside the Catholic Church! Please share this video on Facebook and Twitter using the share button. ▶️ 9. Follow on Social Media: 🔴 Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/SensusFidelium/ 🔴 Sensus Fidelium Twitter: https://https://twitter.com/Sensus_Fidelium 🔴 YouTube: Click Subscribe, then Click "Notification Bell" = 🔔 ▶️ 10. Follow on iTunes: 🔴 https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/sensus-fidelium-catholic-podcast/id1477010758 #Catholic #Sedevacantism #JohnSalza #RobertSiscoe #Papacy #Pope #Ecclesiology #CatholicChurch #CatholicApologetics #TraditionalCatholic #ChurchHistory #CatholicDoctrine #Heresy #CanonLaw #SensusFidelium